December 24th, 2008→

Taking the Spirit Out of Christmas: The Worst Christmas Songs

Published 6 months ago by Morgan Howard in Music → (2 comments) discuss

Not appropriate to do on Christmas...I have a very love/hate relationship with Christmas music. After December 1st, I begin to listen to it even though the radio stations will start to play it in the beginning of November. If I started to listen to it at the beginning of November, I would be pulling out my hair and going mad by the time Christmas came around, so…I play it safe and make sure to start at an appropriate time. Secondly, if Christmas music is bad and it’s overplayed, it can put me in a sour mood and let me tell you, there isn’t a lot of Christmas-related stuff that can do that! I began my Christmas music blog by listing out all of my favorite Christmas songs which soon reminded me of all of my least favorite Christmas songs and unfortunately…this list far outweighed the favorites.


I guess first and foremost, I am not a fan of novelty songs…which you will see in my list for what seems like time and time again. Secondly, just because I do not like the Christmas song listed doesn’t mean that I don’t show some year-round lovin’ to the artist! The song can really, really ruin the artist… especially in the case of Christmas music because you hear it so often and it just reminds you how awful the song really is. For me, hearing the same song over and over again also pinpoints exactly what I do not like about the song and I start to get really particular about the small attributes that make the song what it is.

Christmas is a time for singing, dancing, and celebrating the holiday season…but it’s unfortunately also a time for some really, really bad music. If you have any songs you’d like to add to the list or stick up for one that I’ve placed on there– please feel free to do so! I mean a lot of this in good fun and it should never be taken personally, so keep it light and airy, my loves.

Music: Taking the Spirit Out of Christmas
The Worst Christmas Songs (in random order)
1Grandma Got Run Over By a ReindeerElmo & Patsy

When I was really little, I used to think that this song was funny and it was a lot of fun to sing along with my Grandpa (interesting, I know…haha). Now that I’m older and I can notice the lyrical content and just the overall quality of the song itself, I really don’t like it at all. It doesn’t offend me, it’s just overplayed and rather stupid. Now, my family is from West Virginia and I have nothing but respect for the southern accent…but in the case of this song, the accent just gets under my skin and drives me insane. This would be considered a “novelty” Christmas song.

2I Want a Hippopotamus for ChristmasGayla Peevey

Oh no…this song. Even when I was younger, I didn’t like this song. There is something about Little Miss Peevey’s voice that drives me crazy. Granted, she was only 10 when she recorded this song back in 1953, so I should give her some mad props but eh, I don’t feel like it. I know a lot of people who say that every time this song comes on they will turn it off and I can say that I am one of those people. The lyrics are stupid and it’s just painful to listen to; it’s all of that and it’s also the fact that this song will get stuck in your head. Listen with caution!

3All I Want for Christmas (Is My Two Front Teeth)Various Artists

I recently heard this song performed by the wonderful Nat King Cole and even with his angelic voice it still is a crap song. I know it’s a vintage classic and I should respect it’s charm, but quite honestly when I hear it I just turn it off. It’s especially annoying when they get some little kid to sing it because they don’t have their two front teeth and that’s cute, right?…Right? Unfortunately no, it’s just annoying and can be left in the past for all I care.

4There’s Something Stuck Up in the ChimneyVarious Artists

I’m not entirely sure who the original artist is of this song, but around here they have various elementary school children sing it in a choir which consists of them yelling the lyrics along to the music teacher’s piano accompaniment. It’s also not a favorite when they have the little kid sing it and mispronounce the words for that little extra cute factor. If you’ve never heard the song before, it’s basically about a child’s account of how they’ve waited up for Santa on Christmas and he never came, but there is something stuck up in the chimney. As the song progresses, the length of time progresses and you get new lyrics such as this gem, “There’s something stuck up in the chimney/And I don’t know what it is/But it’s been there all month long/Well, it’s jammed up tight above the fireplace/Now the house smells funny, such a big disgrace.” Hm…that’s a little morbid. I guess my feeling is that a Christmas song is so universal that it really shouldn’t be performed by just anyone. So, unless these kids are prodigy’s, please leave their vocal stylings to the parents ears at the holiday Christmas concert.

5Little Saint NickThe Beach Boys

I love The Beach Boys just as much as anyone else and really respect them as artists. I also respect the fact that they tried to break the rendition mold by making up their own Christmas song, but the only problem is that this song just sorta…well…it stinks. The sound isn’t Christmasy at all, the lyrics are about Santa’s sleigh being a “hot rod”, and the line, “Christmas comes this time each year” bothers me. It seems like it was thrown in there as not to hurt the music and it seems sort of like a no-brainer and sticks out to me like a sore thumb, even over the melodic “Ooooo’s”! I give mad props to these beachy gents for attempting a difficult feat of writing a non-traditional Christmas song that will receive mainstream exposure and be thrown around in well-known Christmas song conversation, but I am just not a fan. A for effort, D for the overall product.

6Little Drummer BoyBob Seger

It is not the content of the song that bothers me, rather it is this particular version performed by Mr. Bob Seger that I really dislike. A funny thing about this song is that when I first heard it on the radio and heard the finishing note of, “me and my dru-uuummmm”, I laughed! I would think that with a professionally recorded song, they would make sure that the quality is great and they would at least audio edit that note if not have Bob rerecord it! I also find it humorous that Bob Seger tries so hard to rock out in this song when there’s really no moment in the song to do this! And lastly, what’s with the saxophone?

7Christmas TimeBryan Adams

This year was the first year that I heard this wonder of a song and as soon as I heard it, I called my mom to ask her if she had heard it and what she thought about it. Long story short, we both ended up laughing because no matter what the song is– Bryan Adams sings it all the same. There is the guitar that really wants to explode into a power solo but has to back down, there is the raspy “Ohhhhhh” belted out by Mr. Adams, and there is so much oomph put into every word sung (to the breaking point of over singing). If you changed the lyrics out and added some fluff about how a woman left him and he wants her back, it really could just go on a normal Bryan Adams CD (think: “(Everything I Do) I Do It For You”). I guess the issue is that I think this song is silly sounding and the fact that I’m not a fan of Bryan Adams in any circumstance may come into play, too.

8Wonderful ChristmasPaul McCartney

Nooo, Paul! Why?!  I have looked around at other “Worst Christmas Songs” lists and this song kept popping up and I have to say that I agree with all of you! I’m not sure what it is that I don’t like about the song; it’s a little bit of everything. The lyrics are very simplistic to the point that I’m not sure what exactly is going on in the song and the synth is annoying! I guess that we just expect so much of Sir Paul McCartney that this song falls short of being anything but easy to ignore. I wonder what it would have been like if The Beatles (John, Paul, George, Ringo) all recorded a Christmas album together, hm…

9Same Old Lang SyneDan Fogelberg

I hate to be the Scrooge right now, but…this isn’t a Christmas song! A New Years Eve song, yes, but a Christmas song? Not at all or in the least bit even if the first verse does state that, “the snow was falling Christmas Eve”. In fact, this song can be reserved to just be played on New Years Eve only and I’d be fine with it. I don’t understand why radio stations insist on playing this with the rest of the Christmas music, but they do. I think this song is way too long, first of all, I’m not entirely sure how long it is…but it seems like it goes on for an eternity, and what is the song about? Well, simple. It’s about Dan running into “his old lover at the grocery store” and then they catch up and well, that’s about it. He sort of boasts that he’s a singer and she is married to an architect who, and I quote, “keeps her warm and safe and dry”. It is what it is and I simply do not like it.

10The Christmas ShoesNewSong

I’m sure that most of you have heard this song and maybe perhaps even seen the made-for-TV movie and if you are anything like me, you detest it. I think the story is fine and it’s one of those uplifting holiday moments that you’re supposed to take in and then reflect on your own life. I think it’s also an attempt to say that Christmas isn’t about the material things, but rather the spirit of giving and the feeling that you get when you do it. If you’ve never heard this song before, it’s about a man who’s wrapping up Christmas shopping and he’s behind a little boy in the line who explains to the cashier that he’s buying these shoes for his dying mother to wear to meet Jesus in Heaven. That’s pretty much the bulk of it. I don’t like this song for many reasons: 1.) it’s a real downer, 2.) I’m not a fan of storytelling songs like this, and 3) you have that children choir again at the end and I’ve already stated I am not a fan of that! The point of the song is decent and I think a lot of people need to be reminded of the spirit of Christmas, however; I don’t like to feel sad after listening to a song; that’s the primary reason why I can’t listen to “Seasons in the Sun” by Terry Jacks

Ho Ho Ho! There you have it, my Worst Christmas Songs list. It was actually pretty difficult to only pick ten songs out of many that I do not like. I also realized during the making of this list that there are a lot more Christmas songs out there that I don’t like than I do! Furthermore, a word on renditions: I’m actually supportive of artists taking a traditional Christmas song and adding their own twist to it, with the perfect example being Trans-Siberian Orchestra. But if you are going to go down this route, you have to decide whether you want to do something totally original or stick to the traditional roots; doing a combination of both makes for a bad song (take Bob Seger, for example). I can’t believe Christmas is almost here and I’m finally starting to get excited about!

Here’s to listening to Christmas music, both good and bad, and enjoying the holiday season!

-M.

Sharetake and pass
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • TwitThis
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Kirtsy
  • Reddit
  • Propeller
  • MisterWong
  • BlinkList
  • Furl
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Comments (1):
    Joan Fowle
    December 26th, 2008 @10:43 AM

    Your list is perfect!!  Some of the songs I have not heard before, but I’m glad you have the hippopotamus song on there!   We did hear a few newer renditions of songs on the way down to Columbus yesterday.  I don’t know who the artists were, but they were pretty bad too.  It was great being with you and Brett!  I hope your 2009 is spectacular!

    Post a Comment:
    You are currently not logged in. → log inregister
    Or, fill out the form below without being logged in and/or registered:

    Pingbacks/Trackbacks (1):
    Pingback
    December 26th, 2008 @5:46 AM

    [...] Vote Taking the Spirit Out of Christmas: The Worst Christmas Songs [...]


    TopOfBlogs Blog Directory Blog Rankings Blog Directory